Nasty hobitses did not mention radioactive particle decay or poison vile! Cat is just dead dead dead!! Suffocated, starved, sensory deprived cat!
The correct answer is yes.
wrong again!
A box without a lid, no way to check on the cat, and no air holes. That cat is dead. It was always going to die.
Going to, but there was no given time frame. So you don’t know if it is dead, yet
By the time you ask the question, you are unquestionably sick, sadistic, & cruel because no one lives long enough to be otherwise.
Eventually dead, from multiple potential causes. Especially with no lid.
Shouldn’t they both be right
Alive and death at the same time. It’s more like asking if the coin is heads or tails when the coin is still spinning.
Luckily, Bilbo remembered to add “Answer fully”
Not if they are both wrong.
Bro the cat is dying
Aren’t we all?




