I just realized I’m taking my ad-free experience in Lemmy for granted. It’s refreshing to have a little corner of the internet that doesn’t slam you with advertising.
Support your fediverse instance if you can, many servers accept donations.
Uh oh! You’ve reached your daily limit of free Lemmy™ posts. Please tap here to spend 45 Lembux™ and refresh your post allowance.
Can I pay with runescape gp?
Only if you promise to be my gf
Oh boy, I haven’t been anyone’s gf in a long time
Here some more LemBux™
My ublock origin icon has been at a steady 0 ads blocked in my entire time browsing Lemmy. It feels weird.
On several sites that counter climbs like crazy. I’m watching a YouTube video right now that’s only 12 minutes long. The uBlock counter just hit 60.
Then you wonder why those sites are so slow sometimes…
I have a youtube tab open, it’s currently at 498 blocks. After writing that, 503.
I haven’t had this page up very long today, but apparently YouTube is on an advertising roll at the moment.
Added bonus: I’m one of the three people in the world who pays for YouTube premium… so the quantity of ads should be much lower.
Oh hey, I’m one of the other two, lol. I think they probably lose money on us at this point, with the amount of ads they serve.
Soon, when things go smoother, I absolutely wouldn’t mind either having ads or paying a low annual fee.
The problem with Reddit was seeking out vulture capital. Turning a small profit, enough to pay people something resembling wages, isn’t a bad thing.
The start of ads seems to always lead to a path of enshitification. One of the reasons I really like jellyfin is because they realized this and intentionally disabled recurrent donations. They saw what it does to Plex and saw the eventually the leadership’s will try to sell out and sell the company or IPO.
Jellyfin saw the way every service seemed to go once the revenue picked up and decided they want to prevent that.
plenty of instances including mine and some massive ones like lemmy.world are fully funded by donations.There’s absolutely no need for ads
Using lemmy is well worth the $5 per month I give them.
Wikipedia is funded via donations, de-centralized social media could be too
Maybe. But I think Wikipedia is easier to run than Reddit, even if it’s only partial Reddit.
I think the option for both would be acceptable, I’d be ok to pay a few bucks to maintain an ad free haven.
If you’re on android, you should try blockada, I don’t have ads whatsoever
or just NextDNS which doesn’t even require anything to be installed
For those who don’t know: DNS blockers can be sketchy unless you’re hosting it yourself. Something like a pihole that you set up would be fine, but external DNS services are almost guaranteed to be data-mining you even worse than the ads and trackers they’re blocking.
It’s a little like free VPNs. The reputable ones cost money, because if you’re not the customer then you’re the product.
that is fair, but your ISP is logging the DNS requests anyway, and NextDNS allows you to turn off logging.
Edit: I also don’t see how it’s worse than ads and trackers, they can only see the domain names of the sites you visit.
There’s a bit of app in your ads.
Wow, I didn’t even notice that.
Sorry about that, added to backlog
It is too crazy for a company as big as Reddit to make a pretty good app that will make you not want to install 3rd party ones? well, seems like it is…
the hilarious part is the entire Reddit app is built on top of Alien Blue, which used to be the de-facto best Reddit app ever. They bought the entire app out way back in 2014 and built the current slow, buggy, security-hole-infested clusterfuck right over the top of what used to be a good app. During the official app beta, every beta tester complained about every problem they still have- poor battery life, shitty performance, unintuitive and space-inefficient UI, excessive ad placement. Reddit made exactly zero changes as a result of this feedback. Nothing has ever been truely fixed.
They could have done literally nothing but put a tiny bit more advertising in to Alien Blue and made every other 3rd party app basically become irrelevant. But no. They are simply outright incompetent and driven by standard corporate middle managers chasing the next KPI.
Fuck Reddit. Fuck Reddit.
During the official app beta, every beta tester complained about every problem they still have- poor battery life, shitty performance, unintuitive and space-inefficient UI, excessive ad placement. Reddit made exactly zero changes as a result of this feedback.
Ah, the Activision Blizzard playbook.
They are simply outright incompetent and driven by standard corporate middle managers chasing the next KPI.
Recent comments from the CEO confirm it. Bloodless money-grubbing techbro shitbag.
Well, kind of. They were already working on the official app. Buying AlienBlue was simply a way to force a migration. AlienBlue actually had very little impact on the official app’s functionality, because they weren’t interested in AlienBlue’s code at all; The buyout was for the user base, not the app itself.
This most recent API change is simply the next step in the process. They realized they couldn’t buy out every single third party app, so they just cut off access instead.
i think it might equally show how challenging it is to design an app that provides the user with an optimal experience.
You’re giving Reddit way too much credit. It’s not that challenging for something as simple as a forum app. The real “challenge” is the very, very large difference between what’s optimal for users, who want content; and what’s optimal for the company, who wants all your data and ad clicks and couldn’t give the tiniest rat’s ass about what the users want.
The official app is built on top of Alien Blue, which used to be considered the ideal user experience. They could have done nothing but OS support updates and it would still be perfectly fine. The entire current unusable clusterfuck is COMPLETELY INTENTIONAL FROM TOP TO BOTTOM.
There’s more than just that to it.
I recently downloaded it so I can save some um research content for later research (I’d been off Reddit for maybe two weeks at this point, I wasn’t going to hurt my pride if I saw the app for myself). When I refreshed the front page of my research throwaway, all the posts were hidden and replaced with new ones. Refresh again, those are gone too, replaced by three or four stragglers. Final refresh and there’s nothing on the front page. They’re practically begging me to go to their algorithm page (popular?). It looks like an A/B test they’re doing, and it looked like others were annoyed at this from the feedback I saw on the official mobile app sub. It was an A/B test with no toggle or anything.
Normally, in an app made to give the user a good experience, this should be a feature you turn on and off. I remember a ton of people swearing by some kind of post hiding system, so, sure, this is definitely a plus for some people. But I’ve refreshed my Reddit home page for over a decade now. Don’t make it misbehave all of a sudden.
Their app, with all its bloat, can have some nice features. For example, during my research session, I was swiping through an album. When it was finished, it swiped into the next post. At first I didn’t like that, but a few posts later, I liked it, I got the hang of it. Decent navigation feature, fine. This isn’t so bad.
I tap into another part of the app a different sub I think, and now the only direction I can scroll is downwards, and instead of showing me the next (image) post, it shows me some random popular vertical video from a different subreddit. Literally just TikTok navigation for Reddit. Which again, would be completely fine, if it was a button I could tap to enter this mode, but not just haphazardly switching between different navigation UXes so that the app can quantify which one makes me see more ads. Fucks sake.
I didn’t even want to download their app, and the one time I find a new feature that I don’t hate, it gets turned off within the same session to serve me a feature I specifically don’t want. I don’t think vertical video is the death of the human experience, but it sure as hell isn’t for me, and it sure as hell is the last thing I want out of a site like Reddit.
These A/B tests infuriate me. I open Instagram every once in a blue moon, and I absolutely despise scrolling down my feed and seeing the same information displayed ten different ways in less than a minute. On one post, the likes counter is bold, on another, it has profile photos, on another, it’s an accented color… like that’s worse than just picking the worst option in my opinion.
But that’s the thing. No first party app will ever be designed to have a good UX first and foremost. That’s secondary. What’s important is their meaningless metrics that make the site worse, so they can charge more for ads (even if they make the site worse for paying users…). I understand that they’re trying to appeal to new people over on Reddit, I genuinely believe there’s nothing wrong with that. But if I stumbled upon it now for the first time, I’d think it was hot unusable garbage, and I would not have guessed this is site would have been my literal front page of the internet™ for over 11 years in another life. Probably would just assume it was a porn site with a weird news aggregator attached.
Dear lord. Random UX changes are among my least favorite things. I have issues with focus/concentration and eyestrain, and I would genuinely rather have a crappy but consistent UX than random changes.
deleted by creator
Reddit’s newest users use it like Tiktok, thus pushing short videos to the front page all the time. It will become a Tiktok clone within the next six months. Mark my words.
done
The fantastic consequences of images in comments.
IMO this already happened. I’ve been seeing too many short videos content on reddit lately. That’s why I’ve been slowly abandoning reddit. Eventually API changes made me switch to lemmy which is turning out fine right now.
Yeah I try to not think about how it’s now normal to see ads everywhere. What kind of normal is that… It’s sick.
OP has a view setting that magnifies ads. In my view setting (as close to third party apps as it gets), the ads take up much less space and there is no trending section. OP is choosing a bad layout to exaggerate their point.
Curious since I never used the official app but are these things opt in or opt out?
I’m not entirely sure but I only changed settings when things bothered me and I never saw this sort of ad. I’m not sure if I even browsed popular before I changed some settings so I’m not an objective judge. My point is, users are not trapped with this sort of ad environment. You use classic view instead of card view and the ads get a little differently annoying. Not huge screen space gobblers but sneaky post-lookalike pests.
Spez thinks that redditors are junkies who are hooked and can’t leave. It was easier than I thought it would be to leave. I only log in once a week for 5 minutes to delete any posts or comments they’ve restored against my will.
Do they really restore manually deleted content?
Reddit admins can and have modified users’ posts/comments in the past, however, the recent reports have mostly been traceable to simple rollbacks and de-privatization of subreddits.
Not all of them are from that. I have had manually deleted comments pop back up with no changes to the subreddits in question. Whether it’s malicious is a different question, of course. I kind of doubt anyone is doing it on purpose. But it does show that deletion on Reddit doesn’t work well enough to comply with EU privacy laws, so that’s fun.
Neither EU law, not BR law, not US-CA law. They’re in for a rude awakening. Also, PSA, check if your profile has been tampered with in any way, as there has been a Lemmy hack.
Thanks for the heads-up. Apparently my instance (Lemmy.one) hadn’t implemented the feature that introduced the vulnerability, and my profile looks fine, but I am going to be taking extra precautions for a while.
And yeah, I think Reddit has been coasting on a combination of user goodwill and a lack of attention to their privacy policies, and now that they’ve burned all the goodwill and shown a variety of weaknesses… I’m looking forward to seeing the lawsuits roll in over the next few years.
What a garbage C-team Reddit has, such a shame
Wait, I can redeem cash prizes?!?
You sure can! You can redeem your prize by selling your account to your closest advertiser!
You just need to win a couple hundred thousand chumba bucks and you’ll be rich!!! I hear 500k is almost a $5 value
I’m sorry bro cause I gotta hide this cause it’s so bad but I appreciate the glimpse into what that place looks like
Seriously thought for a second there when scrolling that lemmy had added ads
It was a horrible feeling man
The author of Lemmy is really tired of ads and big tech so will never happen. :)
Its FOSS as well, so even if they introduce ads for some insane reason, we can fork the software and de-federate the new “adiverse.”
I use Lemmy on desktop browser as I did with Reddit. An interesting note is my uBlock Origin extension shows a counter in the address bar for blocks of any kind. It did a pretty good job of blocking ads on Reddit and I would see pretty big numbers in the counter.
On Lemmy the counter never trips. I don’t think there’s any web site I visit regularly that doesn’t trip at least a few counts. Since my uBO extension is set up to block all kinds of undesirable stuff, not just ads, it demonstrates how clean the coding is for Lemmy.
Kinda reminds me of this scene in Ready Player One https://youtu.be/KpPE85Jogjw
obligatory “charge yo damn phone.”
It was fully charged ten minutes ago, when the official Reddit app started opening.
deleted by creator
Hold on. CASH PRIZES? why wasn’t I told!
That’s worse than last time I used it, which is when they were still giving free awards to use but you had to use their app to get them.
The hottest of garbage
i miss sync for reddit, I don’t miss reddit
Yeah, same. Never saw mess like this on Sync.
in case you didn’t know, sync for Lemmy is coming soon
