I spent hours hunting those big bastards and not a single gut did they drop. C’mon dudes, take one for the team. Daddy needs to upgrade his threads!
I don’t think the red ones drop guts. Silver ones usually do.
I was able to get 3 consistently by doing the Floating Coliseum, it have always been a little low on probability, but you could fast forward to blood moon by doing the blood moon glitch to refresh the Coliseum for relatively fast farming. (Arrow + opal at least 4x with 3x lynel bow.)
Yeah, finally got what I needed at the coliseum. Whew, though. Rough fight.
Silver ones almost always drop them. You gotta fight those ones. There’s a coliseum in the Depths where you fight 5 Lynels in a row, two of which are silver. I get 2-3 guts when I fight them after each blood moon.
Now what was really rare to find was normal, green Lizalfos Tails, because I would only see the blue ones or higher. It was tough to find green ones late in the game, and the tails drop so rarely. It was worse than finding Lynel guts.
Update: You can buy green Lizalfos tails at the Bazaar in Gerudo!
They should drop 4 guts, since I’m fairly certain the bottom part is a cow.