Original post text

Given the recent detainment of a French person who got detained because he said something bad about the current administration in his WhatsApp messages. It makes me wonder if WhatsApp is truly end to end encrypted as they claimed. How did they even single him out?

As a corollary question, if I were to pass Customs, and if I delete WhatsApp , Reddit etc just before I reach the counter, will they be able to find out that I just deleted the apps minutes ago? I’ll be deleting them from my phone but keep them on the cloud.

  • Ofiuco@lemmy.cafe
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    4 days ago

    I’ll like to add something I’ve been saying for a while, the blocking capacities of Lemmy seem to be designed to allow for these propaganda instances/comms/users to stay at least visible, block an instace at user level? no biggie, you still have to deal with their users, defederated? no problem, someone from an instance that links both can just crosspost and it will appear on the feed.
    This gets worse when we take into consideration who the devs are and the instances they own and their usage.

    The problem is those propaganda users, aren’t just contained into those instances, as an example, I moved to an instance that blocks the 3 main propaganda instances but still the only news I keep seeing about my country (🇲🇽) are only those approved by the government… guess what is that called? If I try to call it out I get downvoted (yes, even with those 3 instances defederated), it’s hard to add proof because most critics were kicked out of every media company so they were left with their own blogs or youtube channels (in spanish, obviously) and bots quickly disregard those and there’s just so many that it’s impossible as what it feels like if I was the only mexican on Lemmy (I know I’m not, but feels like it).

    I think YPTB only works if other instance owners and admins actually care about keeping order on their instance, but they are still humans, they can (and will) make mistakes or plain allow some mod to do their shit… because who the fuck knows, until it’s too much/late and they actually have to step in.

    I honestly think the fediverse can work, but Lemmy isn’t it, it’s too lax and too easy to drown in propaganda… hard for anyone that doesn’t speak english and extremely easy to get brigaded if someone doesn’t agree with your instance/nationality (like what happened to mujico and more recently lemmynsfw).

    • PhilipTheBucket@ponder.cat
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      3
      ·
      3 days ago

      Yeah. The whole model is broken. It works most of the time just because most people aren’t propagandists or assholes, but it is more or less helpless at protecting the cultural space against propagandists and assholes.