This is an automated archive made by the Lemmit Bot.

The original was posted on /r/Ultralight by /u/mlite_ on 2025-06-26 14:21:26+00:00.

I’ve been following this forum for several years and have seen many discussions about base weight, ultralight vs. light, and of course, the magical 10 lbs (4.5 kg).

Consistently, the #1 concern about cutting weight further is comfort. Will I be uncomfortable if I do this? A few recent quotes:

I don’t NEED to get under 10 pounds […] but I’d like to be as comfortable as possible.

Suggesting [insert UL suggestion] is quite representative of poor advice along the lines of “have you considered being uncomfortable?”

On the other side are folks suggesting these concerns are overblown. For example:

The worst of it is the “I’ve never tried [UL option], but you shouldn’t try it because [assumptions and unexperienced conjecture].”

They also argue that overemphasizing comfort in camp often comes at the cost of a lighter (and therefore more comfortable) hike.

The debate usually centers around choices like:

• Tarps instead of tents
• Frameless backpacks
• Smaller sleeping pads
• CCF pads
• Minimizing clothing

So, here’s what it boils down to: Are we too concerned about comfort? Can you go UL (<10 lbs) and still be comfortable?