Oh goody, overbroad generalization of ideology with nothing actually new to offer, my favorite!
And what has actually been accomplished within this ‘anti-modern’ framework? Are indigenous people any closer to realizing actual sovereignty using these new anti modern frameworks? Or did we not just witness a genocide of the indigenous which none of the perpetrators will ever be brought to justice?
More importantly, how does abandoning a modern materialist framework help indigenous cause, especially when a large degree of what modern indigenous sovereignty exists is based in the embrace and use of those materialist lens, particularly in the revolutions of the mid 20th century.
The world hasn’t fundamentally changed, the historical forces that existed in the 19th still exist in the 21st, they just have intensified and calcified to make them feel permanent, in the same way monarchy felt permanent in the 16th century.
You are mistaking overwhelming material structural disadvantage as a problem of ideological framing. You can’t just shift your way of thinking and it will suddenly go away and not be a problem.
Oh goody, overbroad generalization of ideology with nothing actually new to offer, my favorite!
And what has actually been accomplished within this ‘anti-modern’ framework? Are indigenous people any closer to realizing actual sovereignty using these new anti modern frameworks? Or did we not just witness a genocide of the indigenous which none of the perpetrators will ever be brought to justice?
More importantly, how does abandoning a modern materialist framework help indigenous cause, especially when a large degree of what modern indigenous sovereignty exists is based in the embrace and use of those materialist lens, particularly in the revolutions of the mid 20th century.
The world hasn’t fundamentally changed, the historical forces that existed in the 19th still exist in the 21st, they just have intensified and calcified to make them feel permanent, in the same way monarchy felt permanent in the 16th century.
You are mistaking overwhelming material structural disadvantage as a problem of ideological framing. You can’t just shift your way of thinking and it will suddenly go away and not be a problem.