My old sandisk SATA ssd was starting to get really slow for some reason. The SMART data and the sandisk SSD dashboard app were saying the SSD was healthy, but its performance wasn’t anywhere near what it was when brand new.

When benchmarked, it was all over the place with looong access times:

Sooo I decided to take the opportunity to upgrade the SSD to something faster - ended up grabbing a Transcend 512GB drive, with onboard DRAM

There were two problems though:

  • My motherboard doesn’t support NVMe (at least officially)
  • My only available PCIe slot is an x1/single lane

After researching, I realised that the single PCIe lane would still give me almost 1GB/s in real world usage - even though its far from the 3GB/s the drive is rated for, it’s double the speed of SATA and it’s worlds apart from my Sandisk ssd lol.

Ordered an NVMe to PCIe adapter, and proceeded to chop up my PCIe slot to make it fit:

PCMR NSFW

It took a while since I don’t own a dremel 🤪

Once that was done, I kapton taped up the exposed metal bits on the NVMe adapter, that could short on a mobo heatsink nearby.

In it goes!! (The GPU went in after the pic lol)

After re running the benchmarks, OMG the speed difference is insane, although it’s limited by that single PCIe lane.

I was caught off guard by something else though. After cloning my existing install to the new NVMe SSD, it booted right up, with the original Sandisk drive gone. My BIOS does not even recognise the NVMe drive as a disk drive, and there are no settings anywhere in there for it.

BIOS person, thank you whoever you are, you saved me needing to do more jank to get my unsupported NVMe drive working!

I am more than happy so far with the dramatic speed increase compared to the SATA drive. I can now actually shut down my desktop when I’m not using it 🥲

    • @DoomBot5@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      509 months ago

      PCIe is extremely flexible. Often times those big 16x slots are actually only wired for 8x or even 4x. The device has to be able to support running on fewer lanes than expected because of stuff like this.

    • Altima NEO
      link
      fedilink
      English
      199 months ago

      Well, its basically running at PCIe 1x. Thats why theres all those notches on the full 16x card. You can install in a 1x, 2x, or 4x header, and it will work. Problem is some cards dont have the notches and need the full connector, but supposedly you can grind off some plastic from the port to make it fit and it will still work.

      • @Kangie@lemmy.srcfiles.zip
        link
        fedilink
        English
        39 months ago

        supposedly you can grind off some plastic from the port to make it fit and it will still work.

        You absolutely can do this, often slots for 1x or 4x slots come with open backs for this reason - it’s better than only wiring up that many lanes in a 16x slot IMO!

        What gets me is the number of people who take a saw to a pci-e card instead of just opening the back of the slot up… :(

    • @SteveTech@programming.dev
      link
      fedilink
      English
      89 months ago

      Also this is PCIe, not PCI. It’s just got a few gaps because it’s actually only x4, and the other pins are just there for stability.

    • @KairuByte@lemmy.dbzer0.com
      link
      fedilink
      English
      89 months ago

      You don’t even need to tape them up. The slot is open ended explicitly for this kind of situation. The extra contacts just dangle and have no power running through them since they aren’t connected.

  • @towerful@programming.dev
    link
    fedilink
    English
    239 months ago

    Cutting the back of x4/x8 slots is pretty common. Some motherboards even have open back slots as default.
    Great work, OP. A very nice and well thought out upgrade (most folk skip the kapton tape).

    It’s worth everyone knowing that pcie slots are generally universally compatible. So a GPU (wanting 16x slot) can run in a 1x physical slot (infact this is how GPU mining expansion rigs work).
    I don’t think I’ve ever encountered a pcie card that will not function at all unless it receives it’s required lanes.

    • qupada
      link
      fedilink
      59 months ago

      I don’t think I’ve ever encountered a pcie card that will not function at all unless it receives it’s required lanes

      One of the few things that’d be problematic would be the x16 -> quad M.2 cards which use PCIe bifurcation.
      Lanes 1-4 from the socket are wired to the first M.2, 5-8 to the 2nd, etc.

      It would still work (by some definition of the word), but in the sense that the first M.2 drive would get 1 lane and any others wouldn’t be connected.

      (Quad M.2 boards with a “PLX” or other PCIe switch chip would work fine with 1 upstream lane serving all 4 drives)

  • theodewere
    link
    fedilink
    18
    edit-2
    9 months ago

    the fact that it fires up without BIOS recognition is cool and weird… that moment it boots after that kind of migration upgrade is like nothing else…

    and i gotta say awesome mod dude… that was one cool ass solution with available hardware…

  • @AnAngryAlpaca@feddit.de
    link
    fedilink
    English
    179 months ago

    How much space was left on the original 256GB disk? A common theme i heard about solid state drives was that speed will suffer the more space is used, so idealy you should keep it ~50% free for optimal performance.

    • 𝒍𝒆𝒎𝒂𝒏𝒏OP
      link
      English
      49 months ago

      The original ssd was rammed full, only about 20GB free. Writing files was super fast - it was mainly reading files that the SSD struggled to do at a palatable speed, often locking up my pc for a few seconds

      With the new SSD i’ve just left the remaining space unallocated, so it’s firmware can freely use that space for whatever it needs to 😁

      • @Vqhm@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        English
        39 months ago

        While this does depend on the drive… you really never want to get above 85-90% full on an SSD.

        It really does depend on how the drive deals with partially filled blocks, caching, and over provisioning…

        But I’ve seen this massive slow down worse than spinning disk on some older Samsung consumer grade drives when full. Now I just shrink the usable space by 10% on a new SSD and don’t worry about it.

        https://pureinfotech.com/why-solid-state-drive-ssd-performance-slows-down/

  • slazer2au
    link
    fedilink
    English
    159 months ago

    Too bad we don’t have a similar community to TechSupportMcGyver

    • 𝒍𝒆𝒎𝒂𝒏𝒏OP
      link
      English
      139 months ago

      Price mainly, and I wanted something that wouldn’t be constrained by a 1x lane in another mobo in future

  • @Anonymousllama@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    109 months ago

    Love seeing a dodgy project come together and deliver real world results 💪

    So long as it’s working that’s all these matters

    • Altima NEO
      link
      fedilink
      English
      109 months ago

      Ive got a few 1x cards. For example, my old home server box has a 1x slot that you can plug in a 1x gpu, or additional networking card, USB, etc.

  • Granixo
    link
    fedilink
    English
    59 months ago

    UNLESS you are limited by budget, (which of course is a perfectly understandable reason) 👍

    It makes zero sense to me as to why would you do all that instead of just getting a motherboard with a M.2 slot and putting the SSD there.

    • @Lem453@lemmy.ca
      link
      fedilink
      English
      259 months ago

      It makes no sense to you why someone would reuse what they have rather than buy something new?

      • Granixo
        link
        fedilink
        English
        29 months ago

        Because it doesn’t look very safe from an electrical standpoint.

        • Anarch157a
          link
          fedilink
          English
          39 months ago

          The only pins that carry power on a PCIe slot are the ones before the 1st notch, those are covered by the slot. all the other are data and low voltage and current limited, so there’s very little risk. On top of that, OP protected those pins with kapton tape to be extra sure.

          Using larger PCIe cards on 1x slot is more common than you think and perfectly safe.

          • Granixo
            link
            fedilink
            English
            29 months ago

            I know it’s very common, but i just hate kapton tape.

            Even if it’s properly applied, it just never look safe for me. (I know, i kinda have OCD over stuff like that.)

          • Granixo
            link
            fedilink
            English
            19 months ago

            CPUs nowadays operate at less than 1 volt, yet it is not recommendable at all to remove them while operating. What are YOU talking about?

  • @JesusRat@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    5
    edit-2
    9 months ago

    That’s a really neat upgrade :) props. I’m guessing you have some additional drives with the bootloader on them. While the bios may not support nvme as a boot device, as long as the boot loader is on a supported drive and supports nvme drives it can boot the nvme drive. Had to do this once with a flash drive.

  • Queue
    link
    fedilink
    English
    49 months ago

    Aren’t you still bound by the limits of the SATA standard? So while the NVMe might have cheaper storage, the speed is bottle necked.