I often daydream about how society would be if we were not forced by society to pigeon hole ourselves into a specialized career for maximizing the profits of capitalists, and sell most of our time for it.

The idea of creating an entire identity for you around your “career” and only specializing in one thing would be ridiculous in another universe. Humans have so much natural potential for breadth, but that is just not compatible with capitalism.

This is evident with how most people develop “hobbies” outside of work, like wood working, gardening, electronics, music, etc. This idea of separating “hobbies” and the thing we do most of our lives (work) is ridiculous.

Here’s how my world could be different if I owned my time and dedicated it to the benefit of my own and my community instead of capitalists:

  • more reading, learning and excusing knowledge with others.
  • learn more handy work, like plumbing and wood working. I love customizing my own home!
  • more gardening
  • participate in the transportation system (picking up shifts to drive a bus for example)
  • become a tour guide for my city
  • cook and bake for my neighbors
  • academic research
  • open source software (and non-software) contributions
  • pick up shifts at a café and make coffee, tea and smoothies for people
  • pick up shifts to clean up public spaces, such as parks or my own neighborhood
  • participate in more than one “professions”. I studied one type of engineering but work in a completely different engineering. This already proves I can do both, so why not do both and others?

Humans do not like the same thing over and over every day. It’s unnatural. But somehow we revolve our whole livelihood around if.

  • @ATQ@lemm.ee
    link
    fedilink
    91 year ago

    You can do this right now, OP. If you don’t like living in a society just fuck off into the wilderness and do you. There are enormous swaths of land in this world where nobody will ever bother you. What’s stopping you?

      • @thantik@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        131 year ago

        Shit is peak lemmy right here. I see this shit everywhere. “I like hotdogs”, “why the fuck do you hate hamburgers you twat?!”…“uh…I didn’t say that?”

        • @Sterile_Technique@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          English
          31 year ago

          So far I’ve seen a lot less of that on Lemmy than other social media. Then again, I’ve been pretty good about blocking people who bring nothing more to the table than just logical fallacies, and the community here is quite a bit smaller than what I’m used to, so scrubbing out just a few morons actually makes an impact here!

      • @ATQ@lemm.ee
        link
        fedilink
        51 year ago

        You asked what we’d do if we weren’t forced to sell most of our time. I suggested a way you wouldn’t have to sell any of your time. So seriously, what’s stopping you? Is it that you want the benefits of the labor of others without contributing up to your own potential?

        • Hot Saucerman
          link
          fedilink
          English
          15
          edit-2
          1 year ago

          Is it that you want the benefits of the labor of others without contributing up to your own potential?

          What, you mean like CEOs and landords?

          • @ATQ@lemm.ee
            link
            fedilink
            81 year ago

            Not at all. Nothing is stopping OP from opting out. And nothing is stopping OP from having hobbies and interests now. The obvious subtext of their question is that OP wants to fuck off and do whatever, as long as it’s easy. They won’t leave because they’d have to work to survive. Which explains pretty much everything about why they don’t have hobbies now and it’s someone else’s fault.

            • Hot Saucerman
              link
              fedilink
              English
              9
              edit-2
              1 year ago

              Actually they won’t leave because in the wilderness, if you fall and break your leg, you die, because there isn’t a hospital nearby to get to. You’re being obtusely reductionist.

              “If you don’t want to contribute in the ways I define as contributing, then go live in the wilderness where you’ll most assuredly die of exposure” is not the grand argument you think it is.

              I have cancer, I didn’t choose it. I literally cannot live without modern medicine. But sure, I can make the choice now to fuck off into the wilderness to pursue my hobbies while dying a horrible painful death. You’re being willfully obtuse.

              • @ATQ@lemm.ee
                link
                fedilink
                41 year ago

                So you’re saying OPs life is massively easier in their current capitalist society? 😂🤣😂

                • Hot Saucerman
                  link
                  fedilink
                  English
                  10
                  edit-2
                  1 year ago

                  Any society offers the same trappings, you fucking nonce. Capitalism doesn’t have ownership of modern living standards.

                  Or are all the roads in China made of dirt and everyone is wearing rags? Last I checked, China is where half our fucking microchips come from.

        • @matcha_addict@lemy.lolOP
          link
          fedilink
          91 year ago

          “oh you dont wanna sell your time? why not just die right there right? surely you would not have to sell your time then!!”

          This is how stupid you sound. And if you read the rest of my post, I will repeat this again, I was talking about how I wish to live in a better society, not outside of society and in the woods. dont project.

          • @ATQ@lemm.ee
            link
            fedilink
            31 year ago

            That’s literally how societies work. You can do everything yourself, or you can cooperate with other people. Cooperating means spending some of your time doing their stuff so they spend some of their time doing your stuff. Cooperating means giving up some free time but probably having more free time overall.

            As is, you can have hobbies and interests now. Society isn’t stopping you from that either. You need to realize that your happiness is your responsibility instead of projecting onto the rest of us.

            A “not stupid” version of your question might have been “what would you like to spend more time doing.” But that’s not the question you asked. You decide to blame society for you being kind of a pathetic person.

            • @irmoz@reddthat.com
              link
              fedilink
              8
              edit-2
              1 year ago

              You can do everything yourself, or you can cooperate with other people.

              Please reread their post. That is what they want, but are unable to do because of capitalism.

              Capitalism does not encourage cooperation. It encourages competition and domination. Competition between businesses and individuals, and domination of the working class by the state and capital.

              The work one has to do under capitalism, i.e. wage labour, is not simply “cooperation”. That would entail an agreement between equals. It is a coercive arrangement enforced by the state in which people must submit to the whims of an employer or else risk joining the ranks of the unemployed, or worse, the homeless, the presence of which is a necessity under capitalism as both a sobering reminder of what’s at stake, and also to ensure there are always more people to employ.

              You can - to a degree - choose who you work for, but to no extent can you choose whether you work.

              • @ATQ@lemm.ee
                link
                fedilink
                21 year ago

                You can - to a degree - choose who you work for, but to no extent can you choose whether you work.

                That’s literally how life and any society works. Let’s rewind all the way to the beginning. If OP doesn’t like working in a society they can fuck off to the wilderness. But! Frontier survival would actually be more work and danger and less free time. Or, OP can move. But it turns out Western societies generally have shorter work weeks than the rest of the world. So what’s OP left with? Misplaced angst and the glaring unwillingness to take control of their own life.

                • @irmoz@reddthat.com
                  link
                  fedilink
                  71 year ago

                  That’s literally how life and any society works.

                  No, it’s really not. Not every society forces you to seek wage labour. This is only the case in capitalism.

                  Let’s rewind all the way to the beginning. If OP doesn’t like working in a society they can fuck off to the wilderness.

                  No, they can’t. The government would hunt them down. But again, it’s not society in general they’re against. It’s capitalism. It’s stunning that you conflate the two.

                  But! Frontier survival would actually be more work and danger and less free time.

                  Okay but they weren’t gonna do that. Nor is it the only way to not have to do wage labour.

                  We could instead transition our economy to one that operates on the basis of need instead of profit. Then people can choose how they work, without it defining their life:

                  For as soon as the distribution of labour comes into being, each man has a particular, exclusive sphere of activity, which is forced upon him and from which he cannot escape. He is a hunter, a fisherman, a herdsman, or a critical critic, and must remain so if he does not want to lose his means of livelihood; while in communist society, where nobody has one exclusive sphere of activity but each can become accomplished in any branch he wishes, society regulates the general production and thus makes it possible for me to do one thing today and another tomorrow, to hunt in the morning, fish in the afternoon, rear cattle in the evening, criticise after dinner, just as I have a mind, without ever becoming hunter, fisherman, herdsman or critic.

                  • Karl Marx, The German Ideology

                  Or, OP can move.

                  Are you really stating this as a genuine option?! Do you know how fucking expensive that is??

                  But it turns out Western societies generally have shorter work weeks than the rest of the world.

                  The “rest of the world” predominantly includes other capitalist societies. Ones which the West forcibly made so, and made subservient, forcing down their wages and strongarming them into supplying us with cheap labour and goods. Not the best point you could have made.

                  So what’s OP left with?

                  Agitating for class consciousness and solidarity with fellow workers

                  Misplaced angst and the glaring unwillingness to take control of their own life.

                  Why is it misplaced? Also, it’s quite clear they are more than willing to take control of their life, but have obstacles in the way.

                  • @ATQ@lemm.ee
                    link
                    fedilink
                    11 year ago

                    Not every society forces you to seek wage labour. This is only the case in capitalism.

                    What’s an example of a society that doesn’t require work?

                    You seem really hung up on the term” wage labor”. That’s not the only way to create or store value. But it is the most efficient. We could completely eliminate “money” but the concept of value would remain. And cooperation would only be more difficult and less efficient if I didn’t want to barter my chicken for your potato. Money, and “wage labor, regardless of who pays your wages, allow for the transfer of goods and services between individuals who don’t need the others goods or services now.

                    The government would hunt them down.

                    No they wouldn’t. Because except for your family and friends, nobody gives a fuck about you. It’s hilarious that y’all think this is even a possibility. I mean seriously, if I went missing tomorrow, would you know or care? And if not, why would anyone else?

                    Are you really stating this as a genuine option?! Do you know how fucking expensive that is??

                    This is absolutely an option. People all over the world do it every day.

                    Agitating for class consciousness and solidarity with fellow workers

                    Moving seems easier, quicker, and more effective. But this could work too. Carry on.

                    Anyway, always fun to chat with college communists. Have a great day.

            • darq
              link
              fedilink
              41 year ago

              That’s literally how societies work.

              There are many ways that societies can work. Criticising the way society currently works is not criticising all possible societies. The options are not “accept things the way they are” and “bugger off into the wilderness”.

              • @ATQ@lemm.ee
                link
                fedilink
                31 year ago

                What’s a society that isn’t premised on cooperation? Capitalism, communism, and essentially every other form of society are simply differences in how the money is divided up. They’re not differences in the belief that members of society have to work.

                The options are not “accept things the way they are” and “bugger off into the wilderness”.

                I mean, OP can move to a different society. OP could also stay and vote but I suspect that type of cooperative government might not be what they’re after. So yeah, in general, acceptance and fucking off are the only two real, immediate, choices OP can make. And in the context of this thread, asking OP this question is a great way to get to the point of their complaint.

                • darq
                  link
                  fedilink
                  51 year ago

                  What’s a society that isn’t premised on cooperation?

                  Are you being deliberately obtuse? Because nowhere has anyone said they oppose cooperation.

                  Capitalism, communism, and essentially every other form of society are simply differences in how the money is divided up.

                  Boy howdy that seems like an ENORMOUS difference.

                  • @ATQ@lemm.ee
                    link
                    fedilink
                    11 year ago

                    Because nowhere has anyone said they oppose cooperation.

                    That is what OP is saying. They want to know what we’d do if we weren’t forced to sell most of our time.

                    Boy howdy that seems like an ENORMOUS difference.

                    I agree. But again, that’s not what OP is talking about. As we’ve established, any society requires cooperative work. Neither you or OP has argued that another system wouldn’t require OP to “sell most of their time.” If you’d like to make this argument you might be interested to start here.

    • Greyscale
      link
      fedilink
      English
      91 year ago

      Where is all this free real estate you’re talking of.

      • @ATQ@lemm.ee
        link
        fedilink
        31 year ago

        Pretty much the entirety of Central Asia, Australia, and everything in the US and Canada from the longitude of the Mississippi River through the west side of the Rockies. It took the US government five years to find Eric Rudolf and he was in a reasonably populated area and they were looking for him.

        • @jawsua
          link
          11 year ago

          Of all the dumb things you’ve said, this is the dumbest. I bet serious money you’ve never lived in any of these areas, and just because less people live there doesn’t mean no one would notice you setting up a farmstead on their property and either call the sheriff or enforce their rights themselves.

          Not to mention the government wanting their taxes or permits and throwing you in jail once they got wind of anything. Homeless people get assaulted, their belongings destroyed, And their lives ruined every single day in even tiny towns in the Midwest. You’re not escaping society there, it’s very conformist. This has big high school libertarian energy