• Lumisal@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    10
    ·
    6 months ago

    Here’s the thing though.

    Supreme court is already captured. Congress is nearly captured.

    If Trump wins, there’s a good chance there won’t be another chance at resolving things even remotely democratically.

    I’ve voted 3rd party in the past when I lived there. But this election really is gonna be one where they can’t be affordable to do.

    This is a “lose the battle to fight the war” situation, because end of the day, ANY choice you make will still result in Palestinians being genocided.

    Voting for Trump, Biden, 3rd Party, or None.

    Unless you yourself have some military training and think you have a shit at straight up assassinating Netanyahu as a random like rogue assassin, there’s nothing you or I can do about that other than protest and boycott. You can still protest the genocide and criticize Biden. You can do campaign for 3rd party support elsewhere. You can still do so when congressional elections come.

    But you won’t have that option at all if Trump wins. The damn dude is literally calling himself a dictator.

    Jan 6th happened.

    You have to lack complete critical thinking skills to think, at this point, giving the guy who’s in the same ideological bed as Putin and Netanyahu a good chance at the presidency, is a good idea.

    • rockSlayer@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      12
      ·
      edit-2
      6 months ago

      giving the guy who’s in the same ideological bed as Putin and Netanyahu a good chance at the presidency, is a good idea.

      My brother in christ, he already has a chance at winning because this country clearly has no mechanism to bar insurrectionists from running, despite a constitutional amendment. I’d also appreciate it if you stopped assuming I haven’t been thinking critically about how I’m going to vote. I’m not going to sit on my ass if he wins, I’m going to fight like hell. I hope you do too. Because it’s already a possibility.

      Do you know which state has the longest running streak of progressive voting presidential elections, as well as some of the highest voter turn out in the country? It’s Minnesota. This beautiful state has been voting to the left since 1974 for Walter Mondale, and consistently has voter turnout of at least 70%. In 2022 the state legislature won a trifecta state government and passed swathes of progressive liberal bills. Do you know our secret? We don’t vote shame, we just encourage everyone to vote their truth.

      • Lumisal@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        8
        ·
        edit-2
        6 months ago

        You think the dictator in chief Trump will let you vote???

        Yes, you do lack critical thinking.

        If by “fight like hell” you mean armed resistance, go ahead. That’ll be the only option left for change at that point. He’s not going to give up power the second time. He barely did the first.

        Glad I left the USA. Dumbasses like you that have zero tact proved and continue proving there’s no hope over there.

          • Lumisal@lemmy.world
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            6
            ·
            6 months ago

            I’ve already mentioned how in the first post of mine replying to you.

            Unfortunately I do not have a Master’s in Teaching so I could clarify any better at this point.

            • rockSlayer@lemmy.world
              link
              fedilink
              arrow-up
              9
              ·
              6 months ago

              lmao, so you’re just assuming things about me and trying to pin me as “lesser” because I disagree with you. I’m glad you left too, that’s one less toxic “vbnw” person in this country. I will never support a genocide. That is my line. If you can’t respect that, then go fuck yourself.

              • Lumisal@lemmy.world
                link
                fedilink
                arrow-up
                6
                ·
                6 months ago

                Not assuming anything. You’ve already shown what you lack.

                You’re still supporting genocide no matter what voting choice you take, including not voting at all.

                Unless you stop paying your taxes at least. I don’t pay US taxes, therefore I’m actually, literally, not supporting a genocide. Leaving the country and renouncing your citizenship is a way to not support the immoral things the USA does too.

                Now all that’s left for you to decide is if you’ll be allowing a greater evil to make things worse, including future genocide - and you have chosen to do so.

                I’m no formal teacher, but I’ll still take a crack at it.

                Let’s say you’re (by force) part a large military group of 1,000 soldiers and a general. This general has ordered y’all to commit some heinous things.

                Soon, however, a new general has a chance at leading the group. He’s one who has done so in the past. He promised he’ll do things that to you, are much worse. He even has an accomplished record.

                Both generals either way have agreed to help a foreign army to annihilate a village currently being razed; but the current general at least might not destroy more future villages, while the new one who wants to take power promises he will, and he’ll go further. In the army you’re currently in, 450 support the new general, 400 support the current general, 20 don’t care , 30 don’t support either but only pick the current one because they think it’s better than the other, and 50, like you, don’t want either.

                Now, obviously you dislike both generals. And there’s this third general who says he’s opposed to destroying villages. So you want to join his side.

                Problem is, his army is only 10 people. Even if you got all 50 of those from your current army to support him, 60 of you can’t stop anything. Especially not the village

                So now I’ll end this with a question: what’s the best option to stop future villages from being destroyed further?

                • rockSlayer@lemmy.world
                  link
                  fedilink
                  arrow-up
                  8
                  ·
                  edit-2
                  6 months ago

                  Aside from lacking all nuance and missing several real world factors in the US I’m sure you missed since you’re not American, I’ll play. Go to the next village with the 12-62 professional soldiers and train them into a guerilla army to violently oppose all those who wish to destroy them. Who would have guessed that military analogies don’t fucking work for politics.

                  Let’s do our best to put that into real world solutions:

                  • A Palestinian state, or a viable path towards a Palestinian state through their own self determination
                  • Restore land and property forcibly seized by settlers
                  • An end to all military funding to the state of Israel
                  • An international coalition army to stand between Israel and Palestine, funded by the US
                  • Brokering a deal with other nearby countries to assist in nation building
                  • Reparations

                  Neither Biden or Trump are willing to do any of those. Electing either will mean we continue to sit and watch as women and children are murdered and thrown into mass graves.

                  • Lumisal@lemmy.world
                    link
                    fedilink
                    arrow-up
                    4
                    ·
                    6 months ago
                    1. I said I don’t live in the USA anymore. I’ve mentioned multiple times indirectly this fact. Practice reading comprehension.

                    2. You’re right, nether will do either of those things. 1 however WILL however try to ensure that those things are not possible, while also doing their best to end any shreds of democracy that do remain AND will lead to even MORE support for more deaths.

                    So, considering that neither will do either of those things, but one will make things worse for future Palestinians (there’s still the West Bank), and push forward into maximum the “women and children are murdered and thrown into mass Graves”, explain to me now how THAT’S better? Or how you not doing everything possible to stop an even higher amount of deaths is more moral than checks notes allowing it to happen?

                    Again, your taxes are still supporting what’s happening. You’re still supporting what’s happening. The final question is, do you want your money being used to turn kids into skeletons, or do you want your money being used to turn kids into skeletons ×2?

                    Because that’s the choices you’re actually being given when it comes to voting and doing something.

                    Of course, if you literally don’t want to participate in either, then go ahead, I encourage that. Cause good trouble. Don’t pay taxes, serve your time, get others to do the same. Or move away and renounce your citizenship. Put your mouth where your money is. You talk the talk but I don’t see you walk the walk. Stop pouting on here about what’s happening and instead do something. Stop commenting about how both are bad and start saying “so that’s why you should join me in doing ___”, and then actually do something about it. I’ve done my time and paid my dues, let’s see if people like you do the same.

                    I know you won’t though. It’s easy to protest, it’s hard to take action. I’ve seen it plenty, and that’s why I finally decided to literally no longer participate in contributing to that system or bother fighting. You can’t fix an utterly broken culture.