- cross-posted to:
- aboringdystopia@lemmy.world
- cross-posted to:
- aboringdystopia@lemmy.world
Health Secretary Wes Streeting has dismissed suggestions that plans to provide weight loss jabs to unemployed people with obesity are “dystopian”.
The UK government is partnering with pharmaceutical giant Lilly who are running a five-year trial in Greater Manchester to test if the weight-loss drug Mounjaro can help get more people back to work and prevent obesity-related diseases to ease the strain on the NHS in England.
The announcement prompted a backlash, with accusations that the government was stigmatising unemployed individuals and reducing people to their economic value.
Speaking on Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg, Streeting said the jabs were part of a broader healthcare plan, adding that he was “not interested in some dystopian future where I involuntarily jab unemployed people who are overweight”.
You must log in or # to comment.
Calling this dystopian is fucking stupid.
It’d be far more dystopian for unemployed people to not be offered effective medication for a condition that causes a shit load of negative health effects.
How fucked are we as a society when we are beginning to see freely available effective medical treatments as being dystopian.
Isn’t the dystopian bit of this the scary capitalism of it? This approach allows the food industry to continue selling people crap that is making them unhealthy rather than reforming their business model, and it’s doing this by handing a massive amount of money to the pharma industry. This is exactly the solution I’d want if I were a wealthy investor with money in lots of vast global businesses, and for me that’s the dystopian bit - the way it’s all about handing money to The Man to continue unhealthy lives rather than, y’know, fix anything a bit
The drug works mostly by them no longer wanting to eat it.
This isn’t a way to lose weight without changing diet, it’s a way to change diet.
Sure, appetite drops a bit in that specific person, but this still doesn’t do anything to motivate the big food industry to change its ways - they can assume that specific person will still eat their products, and can carry on selling ultra-processed food to everyone else
I hear you. But this isn’t necessarily one or the other. I think it’s beneficial to have these types of product available for those who have already become obese, whilst leglistating the food that people are pushed towards eating by the system.
I’m not saying that the government will necessarily do both, but that it’s not an issue with this study that the food available isn’t being managed.
But this drug doesn’t do that. A major way it works is by massively curtailing your appetite.
This literally helps you stop endlessly consuming.
If we’re going to twist this into a thing related to capitalism, then it is an anti-capitalist medication.
It’s the diametric opposite of what you suggest.
E: you’re getting offended at a description of what a drug does. That isn’t normal.
Yeah, I take umbrage with the verbage. It would be dystopian to force people with a high BMI onto the drugs
I wouldn’t say dystopian, I’d say possibly problematic. After all they would be healthier if they weren’t overweight.
However it’s irrelevant because that’s not happening
Wes Streeting as Health Secretary is dystopian, however.
The headline is making it sound bad but there’s nothing but good in here.
All that is happening here is that they are offering weight loss drugs. Your employment states is basically has no bearing on it, it’s just only being offered to unemployed people for now two as it is part of a study to see if being overweight is an impact to finding a job.
We already know that it does. But now we have something that reliably will be able to modify that factor. Actually seems like a fairly good study.
The UK government is partnering with pharmaceutical giant Lilly who are running a five-year trial in Greater Manchester to test if the weight-loss drug Mounjaro can help get more people back to work and prevent obesity-related diseases to ease the strain on the NHS in England.
Slaver class never left…
If the reason you’re out of work is obesity and you can get something for free to help you back into work, how is that not beneficial for everyone?
Or is it better for people to just be stuck on benefits forever?
I am not arguing against that but read between the lines what they are doing here…
- The angle is for the state to pay for this, ie taxapyer. If the drug works, then fine.
- They are not doing this out of good of their heart, western society is in a demographic crisis and labor shortages are a thing. This puts pressure on corporate to pay higher wage. They are allergic to this concept. So here we got capitalism saving capitalism… We are not helping this people because we care we are helping them because the orphan crushing machine requires more orphans.
They are not helping people, they are finding more cheap labor.
I’m not positive that is not just a way to make it more palatable to that class. There’s a very easy connection to make with obesity and it’s related diseases, depression, and unemployment. If you’re trying to do public health with a national health organization, you want to reduce the load of those chronic disease diseases.
If it’s not dystopian, it’s the only part of this government that isn’t.
It was announced really badly though, it did sound like they were going to force it on the unemployed.
