I am still subscribed to slatestarcodex on reddit, and this piece of garbage popped up on my feed. I didn’t actually read the whole thing, but basically the author correctly realizes Trump is ruining everything in the process of getting at “DEI” and “wokism”, but instead of accepting the blame that rightfully falls on Scott Alexander and the author, deflects and blames the “left” elitists. (I put left in quote marks because the author apparently thinks establishment democrats are actually leftist, I fucking wish).
An illustrative quote (of Scott’s that the author agrees with)
We wanted to be able to hold a job without reciting DEI shibboleths or filling in multiple-choice exams about how white people cause earthquakes. Instead we got a thousand scientific studies cancelled because they used the string “trans-” in a sentence on transmembrane proteins.
I don’t really follow their subsequent points, they fail to clarify what they mean… In sofar as “left elites” actually refers to centrist democrats, I actually think the establishment Democrats do have a major piece of blame in that their status quo neoliberalism has been rejected by the public but the Democrat establishment refuse to consider genuinely leftist ideas, but that isn’t the point this author is actually going for… the author is actually upset about Democrats “virtue signaling” and “canceling” and DEI, so they don’t actually have a valid point, if anything the opposite of one.
In case my angry disjointed summary leaves you any doubt the author is a piece of shit:
it feels like Scott has been reading a lot of Richard Hanania, whom I agree with on a lot of points
For reference the ssc discussion: https://www.reddit.com/r/slatestarcodex/comments/1jyjc9z/the_edgelords_were_right_a_response_to_scott/
tldr; author trying to blameshift on Trump fucking everything up while keeping up the exact anti-progressive rhetoric that helped propel Trump to victory.
“We convinced the dumbest people in the country that our made-up problems were real, and now we have a sad because they took us seriously.”
At its heart I think that the real problem. The right has built up “wokeness” into this all-consuming conspiracy theory that is responsible for everything, which was an effective way to take power by offering simple plans that hurt people that large swathes of the voting public already believed had it too good, but now that they’re in power they need to actually do something about this fictitious issue they’ve convinced themselves is at the heart of all problems, and this is what that looks like. There is no simple common-sense policy that would protect people from “being forced to say DEI shibboleths” or whatever they’re whining about because nobody is forcing you to do that in the first place, but you can’t sweep in on a wave of “antiwokism” and do nothing about it.
I’m actually reminded of the similar bizzaro push against “color revolutions” that seems to animate Putin and some of the other crazies in international politics. Like, it’s pretty obviously bullshit if for no other reason than because it it was possible to culturally mind control a people into overthrowing their governments by throwing a relatively tiny sum of money at some artists and shouting a lot there’s no way that the CIA would have gone after Kyrgyzstan and Ukraine but not Russia itself. But a lot of Russian foreign policy, including the invasion of Ukraine, seems to be at least partially in response to this imagined threat from a nonexistent conspiracy, and the blood flowing down the Dnipro is the cost that the world is paying for that delusion.
When people push for this kind of delusional shit for their own political gain I always think of fantasy demonology which goes ‘do not summon that which you cannot put down’. Also why I think lying for political gain (which people keep pushing for the left to also start doing, argh) is such a bad strategy if you care about actual real things and people. And I don’t get it in a way, there is enough bad shit to point to, why make up stuff.
In that vein, Mao’s cultural revolution was one of the stupidest moments in human history. The MAGAs of the world seem rather intent on trying to top it. Have the Proud Boys eaten anyone yet?
My bet, yes but it has not been publicly revealed.
Mitch McConnell shouting “Back! Back I tell you! I am your creator! I command you!” to the shambling form of Trump, who gives zero shits.
I mean… Democrats making dishonest promises of actual leftist solutions would be them making any acknowledgement of actual leftism, so I would count that as net progress compared to their current bland status quo maintenance. But yeah, your overall point is true.