Would you offer the same criticism of someone who quipped about “all men being dangerous?”

Yes, a man didn’t choose to be a man. A republican sure did choose to be a republican, which is a, to put it lightly, dubious choice in this day and age, but I still wouldn’t say all of them are fascist.

Saying that all Israelis should die a painful death is still kinda crazy, and I don’t think it’s “dickish” to point that out.