Actually, saturated soil weighs around 100-120 pounds per cubic foot, which is comparable to concrete (150 lbs/ft³) and much heavier than most people realize - thats why proper structural engineering for green roofs adds significant cost to building projects.
Dirt full of water is not a negligible mass, especially as the total mass will vary and the center of mass will shift around.
But the real problem is water. One of engineering’s most important lessons is “everything leaks”. I think all of these projects are just a recipe for mold intrusion as the water leaks out of the soil box and into the rest of the building.
Fair question, but consider we’re already building to support tons of steel and concrete. Dirt masses nothing compared to that.
Actually, saturated soil weighs around 100-120 pounds per cubic foot, which is comparable to concrete (150 lbs/ft³) and much heavier than most people realize - thats why proper structural engineering for green roofs adds significant cost to building projects.
Dirt full of water is not a negligible mass, especially as the total mass will vary and the center of mass will shift around.
But the real problem is water. One of engineering’s most important lessons is “everything leaks”. I think all of these projects are just a recipe for mold intrusion as the water leaks out of the soil box and into the rest of the building.
Concrete and steal are structural though and they sure just enough to support the building
My understanding that adding green elements requires additional steel and concrete