Ignore whether or not we actually agree with the tragedy of the commons for a moment.

If free land anyone is allowed to use is inevitably going to result in individuals acting in their own self interest depleting the resources of the fields and ultimately bringing about collective ruin… Does that not apply to like… All of capitalism? On the planet?

The capitalists are incentivised to act in their individual interests, and they will do so to the ultimate collective ruin of the entire planet.

That is the tragedy of the commons expanded to an international scale, and if one believes in the tragedy of the commons then one must also believe in the other.

The commons must be centrally controlled and managed in the collective interest.

The market must be centrally controlled and managed in the collective interest.

  • CeffTheCeph@kbin.earth
    4·
    3 months ago

    This is an interesting thought. In neoclassical production theory oil is treated simply as scarce input capital, not as a limited natural resource (as the pasture is considered in the tragedy). If we consider oil as being the common pool resource in our capitalism/free market model, when oil runs out what happens to the market when there are no longer any goods being produced that can go into the supply side?

    Further thought to consider… is oil managed by the free market on a global scale today? Is it state run? Or cartel managed? The tragedy is resolved through cooperative resource management. I wonder what the world would look like if oil was cooperatively managed on a global scale? I don’t mean that there is a global government structure in place that centrally manages oil, I mean a type of cooperative, polycentric governance system?

    • Awoo [she/her]@hexbear.netOPEnglish
      3·
      3 months ago

      Or cartel managed?

      Cartel, generally speaking. The OPEC+ alliance has intentionally withheld oil to inflate prices previously.

      You mention oil but it’s also extremely true for deforestation, fishing, farming and several other things. Including water too actually.

      • CeffTheCeph@kbin.earth
        3·
        3 months ago

        You mention oil but it’s also extremely true for deforestation, fishing, farming and several other things. Including water too actually.

        It is! It seems as though our cut-throat capitalism or our central government models aren’t really the best options for those life essential common pool resources. Can we try the third option next maybe, cooperation?

        Not sure how deep into the tragedy you are but if you are unfamiliar, I’d recommend reading about Elinor_Ostrom’s work in cooperative resource management.