• Hermes [none/use name]@hexbear.net
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      11
      ·
      20 days ago

      Yeah, his arguments on physics stuff is basically “we probably need decades of work on the math part before we find the answer”, and I’m no physicist, but that’s pretty much the least physics conspiracy brained thing to say

  • QuietCupcake [any, they/them]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    12
    ·
    edit-2
    20 days ago

    For anyone running into the paywall:

    https://archive.is/qjPeo

    And just the part about 50 years and nuclear weapons:

    spoiler

    TG: Do you feel that in 50 years, we’ll be closer to having some kind of unified theory that incorporates all the forces?

    DG: Currently, I spend part of my time trying to tell people … that the chances of you living 50 [more] years are very small.
    Due to the danger of nuclear war, you have about 35 years.

    TG: Why do you think that we’ll blow ourselves up, essentially, within 35 years, give or take?

    DG: So it’s a crude estimate. Even after the Cold War ended, [when] we had strategic arms control treaties, all of which have disappeared, there were estimates there was a 1% chance of nuclear war [every year]. Things have gotten so much worse in the last 30 years, as you can see every time you read the newspaper. I feel it’s not a rigorous estimate, that the chances are more likely 2%. So that’s a 1-in-50 chance every year. The expected lifetime, in the case of 2% [per year], is about 35 years. [The expected lifetime is the average time it would take to have had a nuclear war by then. It is calculated using similar equations as those used to determine the “half-life” of a radioactive material.]

    TG: So what do you suggest as remedies to lower that risk?

    DG: We had something called the Nobel Laureate Assembly for reducing the risk of nuclear war in Chicago last year.
    There are steps, which are easy to take — for nations, I mean. For example, talk to each other.
    In the last 10 years, there are no treaties anymore. We’re entering an incredible arms race. We have three super nuclear powers.
    People are talking about using nuclear weapons; there’s a major war going on in the middle of Europe; we’re bombing Iran; India and Pakistan almost went to war.
    OK, so that’s increased the chance [of nuclear war]. I would really like to have a solid estimate — it might be more, and I think I’m being conservative — but a 2% estimate [of nuclear war] in today’s crazy world.

    TG: Do you think we’ll ever get to a place where we get rid of nuclear weapons?

    DG: We’re not recommending that. That’s idealistic, but yes, I hope so. Because if you don’t, there’s always some risk an AI 100 years from now [could launch nuclear weapons], but chances of [humanity] living, with this estimate, 100 years, is very small, and living 200 years is infinitesimal.
    So [the answer to] Fermi’s question of “Where are the civilizations, all the intelligent organisms around the galaxy, and why don’t they talk to us?” is that they’ve killed themselves.
    You asked me to think about the future, and I am obsessed the last few years, thinking about that ‪—‬ not the future of ideas and understanding nature, but of the survival of humanity.

    TG: I think in some ways, during the Cold War, it was easier for people to conceptualize because we had one major enemy. Now there’s chaotic interactions between countries.

    DG: There are now nine nuclear powers. Even three is infinitely more complicated than two. The agreements, the norms between countries, are all falling apart. Weapons are getting crazier. Automation, and perhaps even AI, will be in control of those instruments pretty soon.

    TG: That scares me too ‪—‬ that a lot of weapons are using AI systems to make decisions on some level.

    DG: It’s going to be very hard to resist making AI make decisions because it acts so fast. If you have 20 minutes to decide whether to send a few hundred nuclear armed missiles to both China and Russia for “our dear president,” the military might feel that it’s wiser to make AI make that decision. But if you play with AI, you know that it sometimes hallucinates.

    TG: The problem feels too big for ordinary people to do anything about, which is the same thing with climate change, right?

    DG: People have done something about climate. So that’s something scientists began to warn people about 40 years ago. And they convinced people that’s a real danger.
    It’s a much harder argument to make than about nuclear weapons.
    We made them; we can stop them.

    edit:formatting

  • BeanisBrain [he/him, they/them]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    10
    ·
    edit-2
    20 days ago

    Oh boy is this another one of those “a scientist has an opinion about something outside their field and we’re reporting on it as if they were any more qualified on the subject than a rando off the street” articles

    • BabyTurtles [none/use name]@hexbear.net
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      11
      ·
      20 days ago

      Doctors from the “Nobel Laureate Assembly for the Prevention of Nuclear War” are absolutely more qualified to report on the risks of nuclear war than a randomly picked person off the street.

      He was clear that his estimation is “crude” and “not rigorous”; nuclear holocaust is uncharted territory and noone could truly be considered an expert. I think the average person wildly underestimates how close we are to mutually assured destruction. There’s a natural human tendency towards optimism bias, but it’s probably more likely we kill ourselves off as a species (ie “great filter” solution to the fermi paradox).

  • cosecantphi [he/him, they/them]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    9
    ·
    20 days ago

    Regardless of nuclear war, having a theory of quantum gravity is looking unlikely in this century. The conditions needed to run useful experiments are far beyond the capabilities of human engineering. Without experimental data to constrain the theory, we’re going to be perpetually stumped messing about with math and making claims about quantum gravity in universes that are not our own.

    The problem is similar in scale to trying to derive quantum field theory from Newtonian physics without having electricity or advanced metallurgy.

  • KuroXppi [they/them]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    edit-2
    20 days ago

    For anyone who hit the wall, article tex copied

    spoiler

    Space Astronomy Cosmology ‘The chances of you living 50 years are very small’: Theoretical physicist explains why humanity likely won’t survive to see all the forces unified MEMBER EXCLUSIVE Interview By Tia Ghose published yesterday Live Science spoke with Nobel prize-winning physicist David Gross, who recently received the $3 million Special Breakthrough Prize in Fundamental Physics, about the quest to unite all the forces and why humanity might not live to see a unified theory.

    An illustration of two particles as glowing geodesic shapes surrounded be halos of pink, yellow and blue light The quest to unite gravity with the other three forces has long plagued physicists. Whether we eventually devise a testable “unified” theory remains to be seen. (Image credit: koto_feja via Getty Ima Create a free Live Science Plus account to continue unlimited reading — it’s quick, easy and gives you access to member-only benefits.

    JOIN NOW Already have an account? Sign in here TOPICS Nobel Prize Tia Ghose Tia Ghose Editor-in-Chief (Premium) Tia is the editor-in-chief (premium) and was formerly managing editor and senior writer for Live Science. Her work has appeared in Scientific American, Wired.com, Science News and other outlets. She holds a master’s degree in bioengineering from the University of Washington, a graduate certificate in science writing from UC Santa Cruz and a bachelor’s degree in mechanical engineering from the University of Texas at Austin. Tia was part of a team at the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel that published the Empty Cradles series on preterm births, which won multiple awards, including the 2012 Casey Medal for Meritorious Journalism.

    Read more An illustration of a black hole churning spacetime around it Black Holes Exotic prime numbers could be hiding inside black holes A swirl of blue and red light around a dark black hole in the right side of the image sits on a white grid of blocks showing the fabric of spacetime Black Holes Stephen Hawking’s black hole paradox could be solved — if the universe has 7 dimensions Image of a horizontal oval with many orange and blue dots scattered throughout. Particle Physics Dark matter and neutrinos may interact, hinting at ‘fundamental breakthrough’ in particle physics An illustration showing a spiral galaxy on the left of the image and a swirl of gas and stars on the right connected by a triangle of red laser light Physics & Mathematics ‘Collective hum’ of black holes could settle the debate over new physics An illustration of the Big Bang, with purple, blue and yellow colors spread out from a white glowing light with straight rays coming out in all directions, all over a starry black background. Physics & Mathematics New tweak to Einstein’s relativity could transform our understanding of the Big Bang A deep space image shows the phenomenon of gravitational lensing, with a circular ring of light bubbled around a golden star in the center of the image. The rest of the image seems bulged into a fish-eye circular shape due to the lensing Cosmology Our leading theory of dark matter may be wrong, huge new gravity study hints A colorful image shows a opalescent sphere carving a streak through a rainbow colored surface, kicking up white streaks behind it Particle Physics Physicists recreated the first millisecond after the Big Bang — and found it was surprisingly soupy Two red nuclei are surrounded by blue glowing balls and connected together by yellow and purple lines, all against a purple background Quantum Physics Physicists entangle two moving atoms for the first time, validating ‘spooky’ quantum theory An animation of two black holes mergingPhysics & Mathematics Record-breaking gravitational wave puts Einstein’s relativity to its toughest test yet — and proves him right again Artist's interpretation of the cosmic distance ladder, where each rung of the ladder provides information that can be used to determine the distances at the next higher rung. Space ‘Something’s missing’: Most thorough-ever study of the cosmos proves we still can’t explain how the universe is expanding A pyramid of tan, yellow, orange and red wooden balls are stacked on a wooden surface with a blurry gray background and yellow border around the image Mathematics AI just verified a proof that earned one of math’s most prestigious prizes. Math will never be the same An artist's illustration of a black hole in yellow, blue and pink light Black Holes Science history: Stephen Hawking writes a tiny paper — and turns our understanding of black holes inside out — March 1, 1974 Latest in Cosmology A blue and white map against a dark background. The denser areas indicate regions where galaxies and galaxy clusters have clumped together to form the strands of the cosmic web. Cosmology Largest-ever 3D map of the universe shows 47 million galaxies, from the Milky Way to ‘cosmic noon’ — Space photo of the week A deep space image shows the phenomenon of gravitational lensing, with a circular ring of light bubbled around a golden star in the center of the image. The rest of the image seems bulged into a fish-eye circular shape due to the lensing Cosmology Our leading theory of dark matter may be wrong, huge new gravity study hints A black, starry background with blue blobs representing dark matter Cosmology ‘Invisible scaffolding of the universe’ revealed in ambitious new James Webb telescope images Illustration of the night sky over a dark, mountainous horizon. The sky shows a large spiral galaxy at an angle on the left and a milky white cloud of stars cross the sky vertically on the right. Cosmology Every major galaxy is speeding away from us, except one — and we finally know why An image of a warped galaxy being viewed by the James Webb Space Telescope Cosmology Astronomers spot ‘time-warped’ supernovas whose light both has and hasn’t reached Earth Image of space showing a black sky with hundreds of white dots and a few red, orange, gold and blue dots with halos of light surrounding them. Cosmology Standard model of cosmology holds up in massive 6-year study of the universe orange clouds of dust in space look like mountains in the JWST image Cosmology Our model of the universe is deeply flawed — unless space is actually a ‘sticky’ fluid An illustration of a black hole shrouded in dust Cosmology James Webb telescope saw black holes emerging from ‘cocoons’ near the dawn of time Artist's impression of a forming galaxy cluster in the early Universe: radio jets from active galaxies are embedded in a hot intracluster atmosphere (red), illustrating a large thermal reservoir of gas in the nascent cluster. Cosmology ‘How can all of this be happening?’: Scientists spot massive group of ancient galaxies so hot they shouldn’t exist A photograph of the Atacama Cosmology Telescope in Chile overlaid with a figure from its final data release. The figure shows the direction of magnetic polarization in microwaves from some of the earliest epochs of the universe. Cosmology 30 models of the universe proved wrong by final data from groundbreaking telescope Gamma-ray intensity map superimposed in the corner of an image of a galaxy. Cosmology Did a NASA telescope really ‘see’ dark matter? Strange gamma-rays spark bold claims, but scientists urge caution Two stars blazing within a wispy gas cloud in space Cosmology Two stars spiraling toward catastrophe are putting Einstein’s gravity to the test Latest in Interview a tornado in a field with a road running alongside Weather ‘I’ve seen the movies. What a horrible way to die’: What it’s like to be sucked into a tornado and survive Portrait of Kaveh Madani with a UN flag in the background. Planet Earth ‘In every continent where humans are present, water bankruptcy is manifesting itself’: Exiled Iranian scientist Kaveh Madani on our desperate need to preserve our most precious resource A chemical works at night, with steam illuminated by orange light. Chemistry ‘They are literally everywhere’: The shocking story of how forever chemicals polluted the world A close up of the moon in the darkness of space, its craters and dark maria visible against the gray surface, while its bottom half is covered in shadow. The Moon ‘This generation’s moment’: How the Artemis missions will reframe humanity’s relationship with the moon Hadza man making an arrow Human Evolution ‘That’s why there’s 9 billion of us and not 9 billion of some other primate’: Why our ability to adapt is humanity’s ‘superpower’ Man holding a honeyguide bird in nature reserve Animals ‘It’s nature calling to humans, and humans deciding whether or not to reply’: Why we need to start paying attention to our mutually beneficial relationships with other species An illustration of a human body, with the outer layers transparent and the esophagus a bright red. Health Making a ‘digital twin’ of yourself could revolutionize future surgeries, making medical procedures much more personal A farm in India with trees and buildings in the background Climate change ‘Humans can’t be considered to be separate from the environment’: Award-winning scientist Meha Jain on using satellites and real world experiences to help farmers in India facing a precarious future a person outline and a brain Neuroscience The ‘sweet spot’ of overconfidence — project a bit to be perceived as competent, but don’t be ‘too seduced,’ a cognitive neuroscientist explains in a Q&A photo of two women sitting together, one with their arm around the other as if to comfort her Medicine & Drugs ‘It could revolutionize, completely, the way we treat depression’: Researchers are exploring promising immune therapy for treating psychiatric symptoms an i


    Edit: i failed