At the height of Woke as well.
Kinda funny how much the showrunners fumbled that bag. Anyway Knight of the seven kingdoms is pretty good
I will always upvote redsails articles :)
And I will always post them whenever I have the chance.
Amen
I do love that the following plot line was “Actually it’s bad she freed the slaves because they actually liked being slaves!”
Just pure centrist vibes, nothing is ever good except the status quo!
In the books I remember it as being pretty good, because it’s more “hey if you’re going to do a revolution, you gotta throw out the entrenched powers otherwise you end up like the Paris commune.”
In the eyes of the showrunners this was of course too complex or whatever so they made it into the bullshit that it was. It’s incredibly funny how much those two dinguses fumbled the bag. Really sucks it fucked up a good series along the way.“Actually it’s bad she freed the slaves because they actually liked being slaves!”
I didn’t know JK Rowling wrote for Game of Thrones
Wouldn’t be surprised if the writers were fans of Kid Wizard and the Tropes
Too many people are
Didn’t watch the show, but the books sound like they have a much better take on this storyline. The slaves do in fact enjoy being freed, and the problems are essentially the result of not planning for reaction from the nearby slave cities.
yes the problem is that she listened to her old westerosi advisors who came from nobility and gave mercy to the masters and tried to do reforms and marry into them. She should have gone with her instincts which was to crucify and burn the masters. Her failure to do so ended up in her being betrayed.
GRRM was really using the American reconstruction* as a inspiration for this, and his point is that the slavers should have been brought to justice and they were allowed to fester and overthrow the gains of the abolition. Dany is Abraham Lincoln here basically, and her betrayal at the fighting pits was her assassination in the theater. Difference is she flew off on a dragon.
Difference is she flew off on a dragon.
walking dazed through a heap of burned wood in a roofless theater other than that mrs. lincoln, how was the play?
American reformation
reconstruction?
yes sorry
I think the problem was much larger: she was threatening much of the Essosi economy by freeing slaves. Old Ghis wasn’t touched by her army and she was ultimately headed west, but they still sent troops to Mereen and that other city she freed. Although it almost certainly wasn’t intended this way, there are shades of the imperialist countries invading the Soviet Union after the October Revolution.
dany staying in mareen was definitely her “socialism in one country” moment where she stopped trying to spread the revolution and instead tried to consolidate. GRRM is struggling through the real world difficulties of a revolution and showing his audience how hard this shit is.
The winds of winter, like the winds of history, will absolve Dany
GRRM should have used a 5 year plan for himself.
GRRM is struggling through the real world difficulties of a revolution
Absolutely hilarious rationale for why Book 6 is taking so long
I mean even in books 3-5 that are already out she is doing this and GRRM is demonstrating the complexities and difficulties of revolution. He isn’t saying it’s useless or bad, just that it’s complex and has fits and starts.
I’m agreeing with you! It’s just funny that a very real problem (the complexity of revolution) is likely a huge source of delay.
Yeah. My groans were epic when I recently rewatched that
Theres some interview with RR Martin where he was asked about this scene in the show and he drops a gotcha along the lines of “well in the book theyre never described as being black, it was just a coincidence because we filmed in a country where the extras we hired were all black”
Its posted on youtube somewhere as a “RR Martin owns the libs” kind of thing
https://youtube.com/shorts/grl9ThqokJo
Found the short
I found a YouTube link in your comment. Here are links to the same video on alternative frontends that protect your privacy:
IIRC this scene was filmed in Spain. D&D were going on about how these are all just tanned white people from the Mediterranean.
Didn’t process it before but they’re doing the nazi salute…
This is subtle foreshadowing to Danny being really angry when she hears bells and thus kills a bunch of people, just like Hitler.
Didn’t people compare her to Hillary at the time?
yeah. and those same people went bananatown when the turn came, she ended up believing her own hype, becoming just like her “BURN THEM ALL” mass murdering father. i distinctly remember some complaining loudly that the show did it on purpose to malign Hillary because the showrunners were obviously all bernie bros.
if you read the books you would know that the “heel turn” the show made up made absolutely no sense for Dany’s character and the general non-cynical heroes that GRRM creates. GRRM is really a romantic at heart and his heroes are those “that try to do what is right, even when they fail. The act of trying is what is heroic. The less likely they are to win, the more heroic their stand”.
His world is grim, but it is not grimdark. GRRM creates low lows so that his heroes can overcome the cynicism of the world and achieve high highs.
Dany is GRRMs most empathic and genuinely good person in the entire book series. It makes absolutely no sense she would go evil tyrant over zero foreshadowing or build up in her character arc. She is the ultimate symbol of “fire and blood” to GRRM, which he has used in many short stories even outside of ASOIAF universe to talk about John Brown-esque burning of slavers and liberation at gunpoint. GRRM is a secret “tankie” who support violent revolution and purging of slavers and the like.
I could see Dany being seen as a tyrant by the lords of westeros who hate her reforms, but the showrunners confused that with her actually being a tyrant. That would have been a much more interesting story, Dany saving the world and doing everything right and doing the most moral thing and still being hated as a “foreign queen” by a bunch of reactionary shithead lords.
There’s pretty reasonable evidence in the books alone for Dany going mad. Subtle hints that the show didn’t recreate well. And since the end of Thrones is going to roughly match GRRMs planned ending, then it’s likely that Dany could be ambiguously mad and definitely does some burning.
nope
“My own heroes are the dreamers, those men and women who tried to make the world a better place than when they found it, whether in small ways or great ones. Some succeeded, some failed, most had mixed results… but it is the effort that’s heroic, as I see it. Win or lose, I admire those who fight the good fight.”
This is GRRM talking about his heroes, clearly talking about Jon and Dany. Does this sound like someone who will go insane and kill everyone and become evil? This is such a trope that GRRM will obviously avoid the “swerve”
The “mixed results” he talks about are also the “bittersweet ending” he has described the ending of the series as. The show ending was not “bittersweet” it was rancid and cynical and nihilistic.
if you read the books you would know that the “heel turn” the show made up made absolutely no sense for Dany’s character and the general non-cynical heroes that GRRM creates.
Subverting expectations and all that.
In a similar vein, why did R’Hollor resurrect Jon Snow, when Jon Snow wasn’t at all necessary to killing the big evil prophesied monster?
Jon Snow: “Why was I brought back to life”
Red Priestess: “Your sister is going to kill the night king, and it’d mean a lot to my god if you were there to support her.”
And why did Arya get the face-change powers when they had fuck-all importance to the plot? Chechovs Eldritch power.I could see Dany being seen as a tyrant by the lords of westeros who hate her reforms, but the showrunners confused that with her actually being a tyrant. That would have been a much more interesting story, Dany saving the world and doing everything right and doing the most moral thing and still being hated as a “foreign queen” by a bunch of reactionary shithead lords.
Add to that their idea of a tyrant is “motivated by bells being annoying and the tyranny is killing small folk.” Rather than tyranny being stuff like “hey you can’t just kill peasants and also you have to invest in the state you’re running. Maximum of 4 jousts a year.”
Poor girl didn’t even want to go to Westeros. That was her brothers thing.
His world is grim, but it is not grimdark. GRRM creates low lows so that his heroes can overcome the cynicism of the world and achieve high highs.
Interesting. Most of what I thought I knew about ASoIaF comes from cultural osmosis concerning the show, so I figured the books were just edgy “caring about anything except your own personal gain is stupid and naive” nihilism.
The way you describe them actually reminds me a lot of Red Rising, a book series I happen to love. It’s about the protagonists waging a bloody civil war against a ruthless slave empire with the goal of building an egalitarian republic, and despite the many, many terrible things that happen along the way (Pierce Brown does not pull his punches when it comes to the psychological toll of war on soldiers, the violence and privation a massive civil war inflicts upon the civilian population, or the depraved cruelty of slavers), they keep trying, keep carrying each other, keep holding onto their hope.
The books are honestly pretty good and so is the show up to a point, minus all the SA though.
I think in the future the series will be used as a case study. The last seasons were so bad they completely overwrote the cultural memory of all that lead up to them. It became gambo and had always been gambo. But there’s a reason why everyone and their mum was watching it. The entire internet sat down and watched it together for a reason.
It was good fantasy. Until it wasn’thttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OhA2_aglxxE (13:21 is the relevant part)
If you have 25 minutes to watch some dork comparisons from one of the most knowledgeable folks in the fandom, I’d recommend this video. It really lays out what made the GoT show and specifically the final seasons so terrible, and how they are antithetical to the books.
Knight of the Seven Kingdoms much more accurately reflects the tone of the book series, even asoiaf. The books are colorful not drab like the show, it’s filled with both tragedies and victories, it deeply explores relationships and condemns the feudal systems hypocrisies and problems. You can tell GRRM very much has a daddy-issue with authoritarian rightwing reactionary older men being shitheads, all of his villains are the most patriarchal rich selfish reactionary pieces of shit. All of his heroes are more salt of the earth (Davos and Dunk) or bastards (Jon) or dwarves (Tyrion) or exiled princess sold into slavery (Dany) or women breaking gender norms (Arya and Brienne) or caring mothers (Catelyn).
What the heck, I didn’t know this about ASOIAF. I just thought GRRM just likes to torture and kill the good people while the bad people stay winning and when they start losing, it’s not even a satisfying win for the good guy. Just an underwhelming Pyrrhic victory. ALWAYS subverting expectations with an unsatisfying route to the conclusion. Character arcs that end up fizzling out or completely reversed. This is based on what I read about GRRM giving D&D notes on the final two seasons. AKOTSK I though was GRRM throwing a bone to the people about a miniscule case of “good people” somewhat winning. So was my reading of ASOIAF based on the show completely wrong?
No the bad people get what’s coming too, and the North remembers. There are certainly moments of despair where it looks bleak and the bad guys are winning, but there are also many victories. The first person to get dragons in hundreds of years is like the sweetest most empathetic girl who was sold into slavery, and she uses it to overthrow an entire slave empire and free the slaves. Those that abuse the smallfolk like The Mountain’s men and Vargo Hoat’s clan get their come-uppance eventually, there’s the Brotherhood without Banners getting revenge and fighting dirty for the smallfolk. The evil slaver Valyrian empire was overthrown by assassins from Braavos, a hidden city of escaped slaves. History in general improves. In real ancient times there was some truly horrendous shit, this is like the real world with history that progresses and sometimes has reactionary setbacks. Ned’s good example as a kind and honorable leader made him have so many die hard loyalists they were cleaning up Boltons and Freys and baking them into pies, joining civil wars against the tyrannous abusive new lords.
I hated the girlbossification of Sansa holy shit, it’s why I checked out of the final two seaons when they were airing and only finally watched them last year. I wonder if he touches on that
Sansa’s entire plot in the show is disgusting. Littlefinger selling her to Ramsay Bolton to SA? WTF?!? Littlefinger is obsessed with her and her mom, he would never do that. The show just wanted to have shocking SA scenes and have a SA revenge sideplot. FUCK YOU D AND D
“We abused the young girl character that so many of you hated, and then turned her into a stone cold badass we’ll allow to sit in the same room as her sister you all love (who we also abused), now you can shut up and forget about her entirely”
Will check it out, thanks!
I found a YouTube link in your comment. Here are links to the same video on alternative frontends that protect your privacy:
I never read the books and watched the series with my partner who’d already seen it all.
There’s a lot of foreshadowing about her going coocoo-bananas tbh it’s been a while but I was aware of the criticism of the ending season going in.
That being said there’s a lot of really silly teleporting armies and logistical inconsistency in that last bit. Plus the dragon who got shot from below at the apex of the bolt’s trajectory was soooooooooo bad. There’s no magical physics in westeros as far as i could tell.
GRRM puts a little bit of “madness” into every single Targaryen, even the good ones. Just like John Brown was a little bid mad. It still is definitely not true to Dany’s character to have her become a tyrant for no reason. When you are in her head for thousands of pages it’s more clear how completely bullshit it is.
The show was much more full on cynical, which matches the “trying to fix things is evil actually” cynical centrism of HBO and the showrunners. The books are not like that really, they display terrible stuff happening but they’re filled with hope and idealism and heroism. Things are not futile here, history and people can be changed and improved and society can evolve.
On a similar topic is Jonas Čeika’s analysis of the fash themes in The Dark Knight
If Scary Movie was around back then, they’d have gone crazy with this scene
?? Scary Movie started in 2000. This scene is what, 2013?
There’s like 5 scary movies and the series ran for several years. But I think it was mothballed around the time of this shot.
If rhe fifth one isn’t named 5cary moVie it’s not a proper sequel according to sequel law
Apparently they’re making a new one, but it looks like it’s obsessed with Woke :/
There’s a new Scary Movie coming out this year, so never say never
